Skip to main content

COTY -From the Cutting Floor #1 The difference between mythology and history

 This is the 1st in a series of posts written originally as part of 'Shadows Rising' but that were dropped from the final version. This piece was written after reading an article about including certain myths as part of the Indian history syllabus.

WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN MYTHOLOGY AND HISTORY?

This was a question I felt I would like to pen down some thoughts on 

 At the time of writing this, The NCERT (National Council of Educational Research and Training) in India has recommended that the Ramayana and Mahabharata be included in History. It is unclear if this is ignorance or simple stupidity, but the point stands – there are enough and more examples of people being unable to distinguish between the two.

History is written by the victors but based on objective fact. The propaganda that creeps into a historical narrative when written by the victors rarely becomes fantastical.

Mythology, on the other hand, is an oral tradition that evolved. It isn't meant to remain static and unchanging because it would change based on cultural nuance. . It would include tantalising tales, dastardly deeds and usually battles with more impressive CGI. Mythology, more often than not, also contains moral and ethical lessons that it seeks to impart and educate through characters experiences and dilemmas. The Mahabharat is an obvious example of this approach, particularly the conversation between Arjun and Krishna just before battle begins.

My opinion is that events in the Mahabharata and Ramayana would have a kernel of truth. The tree that has sprouted from them, however, is a bundle of contradictions when you think of all the magical stories within. The sixteen thousand wives of Krishna that he slept with by splitting himself into sixteen thousand separate parts is a good example of this. Believing this happened is a matter of faith. Considering it history is absurd.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rohan is an amateur photographer, an open water scuba diver, a mountaineer, an obsessive bibliophile, an intrepid traveller and a highly successful mutilator of the Spanish and French languages (often at the same time), a consultant in the fields of market research, client partnerships and Artificial Intelligence, an author, and more recently, a dad. Among other hobbies, he can also lay claim to half-baked cooking attempts (no pun intended), chess, computer gaming, badminton, swimming,board gaming, indoor wall climbing, poker, adventure sports, reading fantasy novels, and a string of other very forgettable endeavours. His first novel Keep Calm and Go Crazy - a true story of how he met his wife, was published by Harper Collins India in 2016. His second published piece was a short horror story The School that featured in the Best Asian Speculative Fiction of 2018 anthology. Curse of the Yaksha is his latest novel which is an Urban Fantasy series set in modern day Mumbai. Roha...
2 comments
Read more

An Article by the Asian Review

 https://asian-reviews.com/2025/03/11/fiction-mirrors-the-truths-emotions-and-complexities-of-the-world-we-inhabit-rohan-monteiro/   Fiction mirrors the truths, emotions, and complexities of the world we inhabit.” Rohan Monteiro By dhanukadickwella on 11 Mar 2025 • ( Leave a comment ) Q: Not everyone writes, nor can everyone write. Tell us what inspired you to pick up a pen and start writing, along with a brief introduction of yourself. A: It was 2014. I had just learned I was going to be a dad. I was at that point a research consultant in Singapore in a job and role that wasn’t going anywhere. I felt I needed to do something with my life that my kid (s) would look up to. Something that felt more meaningful instead of sitting in an office all day. That’s when I decided to write a book. My name is Rohan Monteiro, and my first non-fiction novel, ‘Keep Calm and Go Crazy’, was published in 2015 by HarperCollins. My most recent book was relea...
Post a Comment
Read more

Fantasy Land and people are dicks!!

 When I was a kid, something happened that I still remember. Maybe kid is the wrong word — I was in 9th grade, so not exactly small and cuddly but not really an adult either. Was just learning how to deal with the idea that the world is full of all sorts of people. Some could be nice, some could be massive dicks. Case in point, we were at Fantasy Land — an amusement park in Mumbai. My first visit there -I was very excited. There were 5 of us — 2 older aunts and me and my two male cousins My two older cousins did not like the idea of babysitting me — they were a year and 2 years older and decided they would ditch me. I remember being afraid — that I would not find my way back. I had no money, no water, I was thirsty and till today I have no sense of direction. I also remember feeling rejected. I wanted the approval of my older cousins, and here they were, running away. I am not built for anger. I knew even then that if I met them again, I would not be angry with them — maybe I shoul...
Post a Comment
Read more